Skip to Content

Simple 5 Layer Tomato Pie

This 5 Layer Tomato Pie is so easy and delicious, you will be making it again and again.

You know, when you have to think about what to have for dinner and you have absolutely no idea, and very little time to make something, this is IT.

We love savory pies, like our awesome Chicken Pot Pie in Puff Pastry – it’s delish!

This delicious tomato pie freezes really well too, so this could become a staple in your make ahead meal planning.

This is the Best 5 Layer Tomato Pie Recipe that makes up in minutes, with only 6 main ingredients plus a baked pie shell! Just like a BLT but in a pie crust, This 5 Layer Tomato Pie will become a staple in your meal planning.

I used vine ripened tomatoes, and think that Roma would be another good variety.  The trick is to make sure you don’t have too much watery fruit that will turn the mixture soggy.

Baking the pie crust first prevents a soggy pie crust bottom as well.

This is the Best 5 Layer Tomato Pie Recipe that makes up in minutes, with only 6 main ingredients plus a baked pie shell! Just like a BLT but in a pie crust, This 5 Layer Tomato Pie will become a staple in your meal planning.

I made the pie last weekend, and it was amazing! Do you love the fancy ribbon effect on my pie crust?

This is the Best 5 Layer Tomato Pie Recipe that makes up in minutes, with only 6 main ingredients plus a baked pie shell! Just like a BLT but in a pie crust, This 5 Layer Tomato Pie will become a staple in your meal planning.

The original recipe comes from my friend Jonathan, over at our Perfect Pies facebook group, so thanks to Jonathan! If you love pies and baking, this is a wonderful group to share recipes and tips and to show off your pies!

Ingredients

ingredients for tomato pie, tomatoes, pie crust, mayonnaise, green onions, bacon and shredded cheese on a cutting board

Deep dish pie shell baked and cooled.

3 large ripe tomatoes cut into wedges (use Roma or ‘on the vine’ that have low juice content)
3 green onions finely chopped
1 cup sharp cheddar cheese grated
1 cup mayonnaise
4 slices bacon  – cooked crisp and crumbled
1/2 cup Parmesan cheese
1 tsp. Basil
Salt & Pepper to taste
Directions

1st Layer – Tomatoes onions and spices
2nd Layer – One half cup mayonnaise spread over tomatoes
3rd Layer – Sharp cheddar cheese
4th Layer – Tomatoes onions and spices
5th Layer – One half cup mayonnaise spread over tomatoes

 

Layer the bacon and Parmesan cheese on top.

Bake your tomato pie in the bottom third of an oven at 350F degrees/175 C for 40 minutes or until it bubbles and is light brown on top.

Packed with vegetables and goodness you really don’t need anything else at all!

Enjoy!

 

Want more great posts like this 5 Layer Tomato Pie?

This is the Best 5 Layer Tomato Pie Recipe that makes up in minutes, with only 6 main ingredients plus a baked pie shell! Just like a BLT but in a pie crust, This 5 Layer Tomato Pie will become a staple in your meal planning.

Hi there, I'm Judy, it's awesome to meet you! I'm a writer, master pie baker and I've been helping people reach their personal and career goals for over 30 years.   I believe everyone should experience the joy of creating old fashioned recipes, just like Mom or Grandma used to make. And I also help you to create those memories for you and your family with Simple, Delicious, Wholesome recipes that you can learn to make. We also help you discover that Simple Living isn't just a concept.  It's a state of mind. Comforting food and Simple Living. It's all here. You can read more on my About page!

barbecue sauce in two glass mason jars, one with a green rubber sealing ring, on an orange tea towel and a bbq spatula alongside
Best Homemade BBQ Sauce | The Easiest Recipe!
← Read Last Post
Homemade Ice Cream Sauce Trifecta | The Best Sundae Sauces Ever!
Read Next Post →

nicole

Wednesday 10th of February 2016

Pinning this for later! Looks so yummy and unique! Thanks for sharing :) All kinds of flavors in this that I love :)

Felesha

Wednesday 10th of February 2016

Yum! Anything that includes bacon and I'm so IN!!! Yum!

Kristen

Tuesday 9th of February 2016

This looks really good. I love tomatoes.

Tracy @ Served from Scratch

Monday 8th of February 2016

Mmmm tomato pie has been on my must make list! This looks sooo delicious!

Judy

Tuesday 9th of February 2016

Hi Tracy - it really is and so easy to make to. Thanks for your comment!

Michelle | A Dish of Daily Life

Saturday 21st of November 2015

Tomato pie sounds absolutely wonderful! I need to try this!

Judy

Sunday 22nd of November 2015

Thanks Michelle - it is and so easy to make too!